Resources

Client Alerts, News Articles, Blog Posts, & Multimedia

Everything you need to know about BMD and the industry.

Ohio Supreme Court Liquidated Damages Analysis: Hindsight is not 2020!

News Article

In a case decided on February 24, 2016, the Ohio Supreme Court construed the enforceability of a liquidated damages provision in a public works construction contract. The Court held that when evaluating the enforceability of a liquidated damages provision in a construction contract, the court must conduct its analysis prospectively, based on the per diem amount of the liquidated damages at the time the contract is executed, and not retrospectively, based on the total amount of liquidated damages that ultimately accrue.

In reversing the Court of Appeals, the Ohio Supreme Court determined that the mere fact that the liquidated damages totaled $277,900 (calculated at $700 per day times 397 days late) did not result in a finding that the amount of liquidated damages was unreasonable where the base contract amount was $683,300. The flaw in the Court of Appeals reasoning was that it applied a retrospective analysis using hindsight. The long-standing test in Ohio requires the analysis to be considered at the time the parties entered into the contract.

The Ohio Supreme Court also held that “liquidated damages are not deemed a penalty simply because a project consists of new construction of an improvement that did not exist previously and no proof of damages is required to enforce liquidated damages pursuant to such a contract.”

This decision also includes an interesting overview of the Samson Sales tripartite test for distinguishing between an unenforceable penalty clause and a valid liquidated damages clause.

To read the Slip Op. No. 2016-Ohio-628, Boone Coleman Constr., Inc., v. Piketon, visit: http://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/0/2016/2016-Ohio-628.pdf

Should you wish to consult with the author of this article, please feel free to contact Attorney Robert A. Hager at (330) 253–4925.


HIGHLAND COUNTY PRESS: Ohio State Bar Foundation honors 2024 Award Recipients

The Ohio State Bar Foundation (OSBF) proudly recognized the exceptional contributions of attorneys and organizations at the 2024 All Rise Annual Awards Celebration, held Oct. 25 at The Fives in Columbus. This annual event celebrates those who have made a significant impact in communities across Ohio, showcasing the vital role of the legal profession in fostering positive change. BMD Of Counsel Scott P. Sandrock was recognized with the Ramey Award.

NAMAS | Insurance Discrimination - Against the Provider

Insurance discrimination can go beyond protected classes, such as race, national origin, sex, or religion. It can include discrimination against certain providers. The Affordable Care Act prohibits this type of discrimination by insurers when the provider is acting within the scope of their licensure. Once a proposed rule to implement this protection is in place, there could be wide-reaching reimbursement implications.

BMD Named to the 2025 Best Lawyers® “Best Law Firms”

Brennan Manna & Diamond (BMD) is recognized among the leading law firms in the nation according to the 2025 Edition of Best Lawyers®  "Best Law Firms." The firm is recognized in the metropolitan areas of Akron, Cleveland, Fort Myers (Bonita Springs office), Jacksonville, and Orlando.

Legal Aid Society: Scott Heasley

The Legal Aid Society of Cleveland highlights BMD Partner Scott Heasley and his volunteer work with Legal Aid.

The BMD Orlando Team Closes $81.5 Million Real Estate Land Transaction

The BMD Orlando Team successfully closed a $81.5 million and 1,800-acre real estate land transaction as part of a massive land deal. The legal team included BMD Senior Counsel Kim Gray, Member Scott Rost, Senior Counsel Audrey Wanich.